Skip to content
iGaming Times

Choose your emails

Which emails would you like?

Independent industry intelligence in your inbox. We will email you a link to confirm the emails you ticked, and every email carries a one-click unsubscribe link. Each list can be left on its own.

Prediction Markets

AGA Poll Finds 82% Want Prediction Markets Regulated as Gambling

Antonina TupikovaBy Antonina Tupikova · Founder, iGaming Times2 min read
The white marble Lincoln Memorial in Washington, DC, under a blue sky, with visitors on its steps and trees beside it

The casino industry's trade body has put a number on public opinion just as the federal government sues states over the exchanges. The question it asked, and who it asked, matter as much as the headline figure.

  • The American Gaming Association (AGA) said on 16 November that 82% of respondents to its American Attitudes survey want prediction markets regulated as gambling, not financial, products
  • Agreement was 84% among Democrats, 82% among Republicans and 80% among independents, in an online survey of 2,268 registered voters aged 21 and older
  • Some 75% agreed that sports betting on a prediction market is fundamentally the same product as betting at a sportsbook, and 50% believed prediction markets are state-licensed sportsbooks
  • The AGA, whose members run state-licensed sportsbooks, has told the Supreme Court the CFTC is not a betting regulator
  • The poll lands three days after the CFTC sued Louisiana to stop a state court order shutting the exchanges out

The Casino Lobby Says Voters of Every Party See Prediction Markets as Gambling

The American Gaming Association published the results in a release on Monday 16 November. The survey was conducted online on Qualtrics from 2 to 18 September among what the AGA calls a nationally representative sample of 2,268 registered voters aged 21 and older, with a margin of error of plus or minus 2 percentage points at the 95% confidence level, higher for subgroups. Semafor first reported the findings on 13 November, with a two-page AGA summary.

The summary gives the main question: "In your opinion, should prediction markets be regulated as gambling products like sports bets, or financial products like swaps or futures contracts?" Some 82% chose gambling. A second asked respondents to agree or disagree that "Sports betting on a prediction market is fundamentally the same product as betting at a sportsbook"; the AGA reports 75% agreement. The shares choosing the other answers are not published.

According to the release, 74% said the platforms should verify that every user is at least 21, 74% that their adverts should carry responsible gaming messages and a helpline, 71% that the state gaming regulator should license them, and 70% that they should honour state self-exclusion lists. It says 50% of Americans "wrongfully believe" prediction markets are state-licensed sportsbooks, and that prediction market users see sports contracts as no riskier than a 30-year mortgage or the stock market. Neither the wording of those questions nor the number of users surveyed is published.

iGaming glossary: 430+ terms explained.

"Insidiously misrepresenting sports betting as an investment to 18-year-olds, and telling them it can pay their rent or college tuition, is a grotesque business practice," said AGA President and CEO Bill Miller, adding that it undermines decades of work by industry, state and tribal regulators.

On gambling generally, 88% called it an acceptable form of entertainment and 52% gambled in the past year. The AGA estimates that 113 million adults, 44% of Americans, visited a casino in that period.

The Question Was Broader Than the Headline

The release's headline is about sports betting, but the 82% question asked about prediction markets in general, and each answer carried an example, "sports bets" or "swaps or futures contracts". The summary does not show whether "not sure" was offered, which matters for a product many respondents may not have used. The sample was registered voters aged 21 and over, reported throughout as "Americans", so the 18-year-olds Miller describes were not asked. The AGA does not say how the online sample was drawn or weighted, which is what the quoted margin of error depends on.

The Audience Is the Senate and the Courts

Pre-emption will be decided on the Commodity Exchange Act, not on opinion. The poll serves AGA members whose sportsbooks compete with CFTC-registered exchanges, and repeats the case of its September financial literacy study against selling sports contracts as investing. It arrives as the CFTC sues Arkansas and Louisiana and two nominees to the commission await the Senate Agriculture Committee, where a bipartisan number counts for more than in court. The figure with legal bite is the 50% who think prediction markets are state-licensed sportsbooks: state cases lean on consumer protection law, and the Louisiana order the CFTC is fighting barred the exchanges from telling residents their products are lawful. Evidence of public confusion supports that line, if the unpublished question behind it holds up.

The AGA has a credible bipartisan number and an interest in every digit of it. Until the full questionnaire is published, it is a lobbying tool first and a measure of opinion second.

Sources

Citations and primary documents this article references. Captured at the time of writing.

Comments

Be the first to comment.

Cookie Preferences

Choose which cookies you want to accept. Essential cookies are required for the website to function properly.

Required

Necessary for the website to function. Cannot be disabled.

Help us understand how visitors interact with our website.

Used to deliver relevant advertisements and track ad performance.

Remember your preferences and settings for a better experience.