EU Court Rejects Austrian Questions on Malta's Gaming Law Without Ruling on It
By Antonina Tupikova · Founder, iGaming Times2 min read
The EU's top court has declared inadmissible an Austrian court's questions on Malta's 2023 shield against foreign player-refund judgments, because the case behind them is a claim against a legal advisor. The Court has still not ruled on whether the shield complies with EU law.
- The Court of Justice of the European Union ruled on 19 November in Case C-683/24 that a reference from the Commercial Court, Vienna, is inadmissible
- The Vienna case is a damages claim by an Austrian litigation funder against a legal advisor who called Malta's June 2023 gaming law amendment manifestly contrary to EU law
- According to the Court's press release, the advisor's liability does not depend on the Maltese law's compatibility with EU law
- The Court did not decide whether the Maltese provision blocking foreign player-refund judgments is compatible with EU law
- Advocate General Nicholas Emiliou proposed the same outcome in April, while finding the provision manifestly incompatible with the Brussels I bis Regulation in the alternative
The Court Found No Real Link Between the Questions and the Vienna Dispute
The Court of Justice of the European Union (CJEU) gave judgment in Case C-683/24, Spielerschutz Sigma, on 19 November, declaring inadmissible the questions referred by the Commercial Court, Vienna (Handelsgericht Wien). According to the Court's press release No 167/26, an unofficial summary for the media, the answers were not needed to decide the Austrian dispute.
Spielerschutz Sigma Prozessfinanzierungs GmbH, an Austrian company, funds claims by online players in Austria against Maltese-licensed operators, on the ground that they offer services there without the licence Austrian law requires. According to the Court, players can on that basis recover their losses in the Austrian courts, and Spielerschutz Sigma has obtained numerous such judgments, which it is seeking to enforce in Malta.
In June 2023, Malta amended its gaming legislation to prohibit, as contrary to public policy, actions against Maltese licensees and the recognition and enforcement of foreign judgments given in such actions. A legal advisor told Spielerschutz Sigma that the amendment was manifestly in conflict with EU law and would not be applied in enforcement proceedings in Malta. A Maltese court later refused to recognise and enforce one of the company's Austrian judgments, relying on the amendment.
Spielerschutz Sigma then sued the advisor in Vienna for the opinion's fees and the cost of funding proceedings until it learned of that refusal. Considering that the outcome turned on whether the advisor was at fault in assessing the Maltese law, the Vienna court referred several questions to Luxembourg.

Liability Turns on Austrian Law, Not on the Maltese Provision
According to the press release, the Court held that a national court may refer questions only where the answer is needed to decide its dispute, through a link that is real and concrete, not hypothetical or speculative. Under Austrian law, the test is whether the opinion was at the very least reasonably defensible when given; if it was consistent with at least some case law or legal literature, the advisor would not be liable.
The Court found that the parties' obligations under the consultation were independent of whether the Maltese legislation is compatible with EU law, so the questions sought advisory opinions on general or hypothetical points. It gave no answer on the substance.
The Advocate General Had Gone Further
Advocate General Nicholas Emiliou delivered an Opinion in the case on 23 April 2026 (ECLI:EU:C:2026:351). According to the Court's press release No 65/26, the Advocate General also proposed inadmissibility, because the issue in Vienna was whether the advisor's assessment was diligent when made.
The Advocate General then addressed the substance. The release identifies the provision as Article 56A of the Gaming Act, introduced by Bill 55 of 2023, and reports the view that it is manifestly incompatible with the Brussels I bis Regulation's rules on recognising and enforcing judgments, which Malta cannot justify under the regulation's public policy clause. The Opinion does not bind the Court, and the judgment, as summarised, does not take up that analysis.
The Judgment Settles Procedure, Not the Maltese Shield
The press release records no view on whether Malta's 2023 amendment is compatible with EU law; the Court asked only whether a claim against an advisor needed the answer. The only analysis of the substance in this case is the Advocate General's non-binding Opinion. The European Commission's infringement proceedings against Malta over the same provision, reported by iGT in June 2025, are not mentioned in the press release.
Related Cases
The press release sets out the model at stake: Austrian players win refund judgments at home, and a funder seeks to enforce them in Malta, where at least one court has refused recognition under the 2023 amendment. Separately, Malta's detailed opinion has kept Austria's online gambling reform in standstill until 7 December, and German players have brought similar claims, as in the legal fight over bet365's Maltese protection.


