Skip to content
iGaming Times

Choose your emails

Which emails would you like?

Independent industry intelligence in your inbox. We will email you a link to confirm the emails you ticked, and every email carries a one-click unsubscribe link. Each list can be left on its own.

Regulatory

Chile's Supreme Court Tells Senate a Betting Site Blocking Bill Is Unnecessary

Antonina TupikovaBy Antonina Tupikova · Founder, iGaming Times2 min read
The Santiago skyline at dusk, with the Gran Torre Costanera and the snow-capped Andes behind

Chile's Supreme Court has told the Senate that a bill written to stop betting platforms dodging court-ordered blocks with mirror sites adds nothing to the powers judges already have. It says any fix belongs in the telecoms law or the casino law, not the Code of Civil Procedure.

  • Chile's Supreme Court sent the Senate its report on bill Boletín 18.699-07 on 12 November, after the full court discussed it on 9 November
  • The bill would add three articles to the Code of Civil Procedure so courts can extend blocking orders to new domains, subdomains and mirror sites and sanction internet providers and platforms that do not comply
  • The court found the articles "unnecessary and superfluous" because existing enforcement rules, including Article 240 of the code, already let judges undo anything done in breach of an order
  • It recommended amending the General Telecommunications Law or the casino law instead, the route already taken by a ban text the Senate Economy Committee backed on 9 November
  • The bill follows months of DNS blocking orders that mirror sites have sidestepped, including 37 further domains Subtel ordered blocked in September

The Court Says the Bill Misses the Problem It Was Written to Solve

The Supreme Court of Chile sent the Senate Oficio No. 314-2026 on 12 November, its report on a bill that "modifies the Code of Civil Procedure to regulate the enforcement of court rulings blocking websites and online platforms", according to the Poder Judicial. The full court, sitting as the Tribunal Pleno and presided over by Gloria Ana Chevesich Ruiz, considered the bill on 9 November; the resolution is dated 11 November. The Senate had asked for the court's view on 30 September under Article 77 of the Constitution, which requires the court to be heard on bills affecting the organisation and powers of the courts.

The bill, Boletín 18.699-07, was filed on 30 September by senators Alejandra Sepúlveda Orbenes and Esteban Velásquez Núñez, according to the Senate's legislative record. It sits with the Senate's Constitution, Legislation, Justice and Rules Committee with no urgency, and the Senate logged the court's report on 17 November.

According to the report, the bill would insert Articles 238 bis, 238 ter and 238 quáter into the code. The first would require internet providers to block the domains an order names within its deadline and report compliance, and let the court extend the order to new domains or mirror sites that technical evidence links to the original platform. The other two would let courts demand information from providers and platforms that fail to comply and impose coercive measures.

iGaming glossary: 430+ terms explained.

Judges Already Have the Powers, the Court Says

The court's first objection is a mismatch. The bill's preamble names the problem as "the deliberate use of technological mechanisms by online betting platforms to keep operating in defiance of court-ordered blocking", the report notes, yet none of the three articles mentions online betting. Written as a general rule for every blocking order, the articles "appear unnecessary and superfluous" next to the existing enforcement rules in Title XIX of Book I of the code (translations from the Spanish are ours).

The report points to Articles 235 to 238, and above all Article 240, under which a court may "order measures aimed at undoing anything done in contravention" of a ruling, and anyone who breaches what was ordered faces a prison term. That rule "by itself would seem to render pointless" what the new articles attempt, the court said. Until the bill is confined to the specific problem, the court concluded, it adds nothing to the judge's existing enforcement powers.

Narrowing it to betting would create a second problem, the court said. Book I holds the provisions common to all civil procedure and also applies in criminal cases, and rules as specific as the duties of internet providers would undermine its general character. The court recommended the General Telecommunications Law, Law 18.168, which governs internet providers and the sanctioning powers of the telecoms undersecretariat, Subtel, or Law 19.995 on casinos and the Superintendencia de Casinos de Juego (SCJ).

It closed with a broader warning: the problem the bill seeks to remedy "may lie in other factors unrelated to any insufficiency in the courts' enforcement powers".

Existing Blocking Orders

Chile's blocking regime rests on court rulings won by Lotería de Concepción, which led the Santiago Court of Appeals to set a DNS blocking protocol in August and Subtel to send providers 79 domains in September. The report does not question that blocking; it says judges can already enforce it, and points any new rules on mirror sites to the laws that govern Subtel and the SCJ. The report is advisory, and the bill stays with the Constitution Committee.

Blocking in the Betting Bill

Chile's online gambling bill, Boletín 14.838-03, already hands the SCJ a blocking role in one text. The ban text by senators Diego Ibáñez and Gastón Saavedra that the Economy Committee approved on 9 November would oblige providers, app stores and payment firms to block platforms within five days of notice from the SCJ. The government's rival amendments, which pair a 22% tax with an advertising ban, sit in the same bill.

Sources

Citations and primary documents this article references. Captured at the time of writing.

Comments

Be the first to comment.

Cookie Preferences

Choose which cookies you want to accept. Essential cookies are required for the website to function properly.

Required

Necessary for the website to function. Cannot be disabled.

Help us understand how visitors interact with our website.

Used to deliver relevant advertisements and track ad performance.

Remember your preferences and settings for a better experience.