Skip to content
iGaming Times

Choose your emails

Which emails would you like?

Independent industry intelligence in your inbox. We will email you a link to confirm the emails you ticked, and every email carries a one-click unsubscribe link. Each list can be left on its own.

Regulatory

Italy Had to Notify Its Gambling Ad Ban to the Commission, Advocate General Says

Antonina TupikovaBy Antonina Tupikova · Founder, iGaming Times2 min read
The Colosseum in Rome at golden hour under a clear blue sky, with a paved square and trees in the foreground

Advocate General Maciej Szpunar has told the EU Court of Justice that the Dignity Decree's advertising ban is a technical rule Italy had to notify in draft, in LeoVegas's challenge to a €50,000 fine. The Opinion limits the consequence to advertising a user requests online and finds a total ban compatible with EU law if proportionate.

  • Advocate General Maciej Szpunar delivered an Opinion in Case C-194/25, Leovegas Gaming, on 19 November, proposing that a ban on all gambling advertising on any medium, including the internet, is a technical rule that must be notified in draft to the European Commission
  • The case arises from a €50,000 fine AGCOM imposed on 17 October 2019 for gambling advertising on channel 237 of the Sky platform, under Article 9 of the 2018 Dignity Decree
  • On the Opinion's reading, an operator can rely on a failure to notify only for infringements committed in providing information society services, which excludes linear broadcast advertising
  • The Advocate General found that Article 49 TFEU does not preclude a total gambling advertising ban, provided it is proportionate and respects legitimate expectations
  • The Opinion is not binding: the Court of Justice will rule later, and the Consiglio di Stato will then decide LeoVegas's appeal

An Italian Fine for Sky Channel Advertising Reaches Luxembourg

The Opinion of Advocate General Szpunar, delivered on 19 November, answers four questions from Italy's Consiglio di Stato (Council of State) in a dispute between Leovegas Gaming plc and the Autorità per le Garanzie nelle Comunicazioni (AGCOM).

According to the Consiglio di Stato's request, lodged on 11 March 2025, the Malta-registered company has operated in Italy since 2017 under a licence from the Customs and Monopolies Agency (ADM), including on channel 237 of the Sky television platform. AGCOM fined it €50,000 on 17 October 2019 for advertising several of its games there, in breach of Article 9 of Decree-Law No 87 of 12 July 2018, which bans any form of gambling advertising. The penalty is 20% of the advertising's value, with a €50,000 minimum. The Lazio Regional Administrative Court dismissed LeoVegas's challenge.

LeoVegas argues that Article 9 is a technical rule under Directive 2015/1535, the EU notification procedure for technical regulations and rules on information society services, and that because Italy did not notify it, the court must disapply it. A hearing was held on 1 July 2026.

Notification Required, but the Sanction Is Limited to Online Services

The Advocate General proposes that a ban on gambling advertising on any medium, including the internet, is a technical rule whose draft must go to the Commission. Article 9 expressly names digital and telematic channels, including social media, and its effect on online providers was examined during the legislative process, so it does not concern online services only incidentally, the Opinion says.

iGaming glossary: 430+ terms explained.

Under settled case law, an unnotified technical rule cannot be enforced against individuals, whatever value it protects. The Opinion narrows that: an operator may rely on the defect only where the rule was applied to an infringement committed in providing information society services. For other services the law applies as normal; otherwise, the Opinion reasons, member states could sidestep the sanction by splitting legislation.

Advertising is an information society service only when it reaches a recipient through a transmission initiated at that recipient's individual request. Linear advertising to an indeterminate audience is not, even alongside interactive television features, and the Consiglio di Stato must decide which describes the advertising at issue. LeoVegas told the hearing that playing through the channel required registration on its website, the Opinion records.

The Advocate General applied Article 49 TFEU, given LeoVegas's long-term concession, and found it does not preclude a total ban. The Opinion rejected the argument that allowing advertising for licensed gambling would be less restrictive, because Italy's aim is to reduce incentives to gamble in general, perhaps especially on licensed games. Whether implementation respected legitimate expectations is for the national court.

What the Test Means for the Sky Fine

The fine concerned advertising on a Sky channel. Under the Opinion, linear broadcasting is not an information society service, while LeoVegas told the hearing that playing through the channel required registration on its website. How that advertising is characterised is for the Consiglio di Stato.

AGCOM's Online Rules

Article 9 empowers AGCOM to fine, and the regulator is consulting on how its 2019 guidelines treat betting brands' infotainment sites. On the Opinion's reading, advertising delivered at a user's request is where a failure to notify would make the ban unenforceable. That Italy did not notify is LeoVegas's assertion, not a finding of the Opinion.

A Wide Margin for Member States

The Advocate General gave Italy a wide margin, citing case law on the moral, religious and cultural divergence between member states over gambling, and dismissed the equal treatment argument because illegal gambling advertising is banned as a consequence of banning illegal gambling itself.

Sources

Citations and primary documents this article references. Captured at the time of writing.

Comments

Be the first to comment.

Cookie Preferences

Choose which cookies you want to accept. Essential cookies are required for the website to function properly.

Required

Necessary for the website to function. Cannot be disabled.

Help us understand how visitors interact with our website.

Used to deliver relevant advertisements and track ad performance.

Remember your preferences and settings for a better experience.