Skip to content
iGaming Times

Choose your emails

Which emails would you like?

Independent industry intelligence in your inbox. We will email you a link to confirm the emails you ticked, and every email carries a one-click unsubscribe link. Each list can be left on its own.

Sports Betting

Clase Prosecutors Fight a Missing Witness Instruction Over Enoc Pena

Antonina TupikovaBy Antonina Tupikova · Founder, iGaming Times2 min read
An empty wood-panelled courtroom in the United States with flags behind the judge's bench

The court's draft jury charge in the Brooklyn pitch-rigging trial would address the absence of Enoc Pena, the cooperating bettor prosecutors have chosen not to call. The government says the defendants repeatedly moved to keep Pena off the stand and cannot now claim a missing witness charge.

  • The court docketed a draft verdict sheet on 18 November in the trial of Emmanuel Clase, Luis Ortiz and Robinson Vasquez Germosen, in a filing that prosecutors say also contains the proposed jury charge
  • The draft verdict sheet puts all three defendants on Count One, wire fraud conspiracy, but only Clase and Ortiz on the honest services, sports bribery and money laundering counts
  • On 19 November prosecutors asked the court to remove a "missing witness" instruction from the charge, confirming they have decided not to call cooperating witness Enoc Pena
  • Pena's lawyer told both sides as recently as 17 November that Pena is "prepared to testify for either side in the trial if called as a witness", the government says
  • Prosecutors want the issue settled before the charging conference and before they rest, and ask the court to tell jurors to draw no inference against either side

The Brooklyn Trial Reaches the Jury Instructions Stage

The trial before Judge Kiyo A. Matsumoto in the United States District Court for the Eastern District of New York sat on 12, 13, 16, 17, 18 and 19 November, the docket shows. Minute entries for the first four days record witnesses sworn and exhibits entered. The court record names the defendants as Emmanuel Clase de la Cruz, Luis Leandro Ortiz Ribera and Robinson Vasquez Germosen.

On 18 November the court docketed an order attaching a draft verdict sheet, marked Court Exhibit 1A, which lists four counts. All three defendants face Count One, wire fraud conspiracy, which the November 2025 indictment frames as a scheme to defraud two unnamed sportsbooks whose terms of use barred wagers placed on non-public information from an athlete. Only Clase and Ortiz face Count Two, honest services wire fraud conspiracy, in which the indictment names the Cleveland Guardians and MLB as the parties deprived; Count Three, conspiracy to influence sporting contests by bribery; and Count Four, money laundering conspiracy.

According to the government, the same filing contains the court's proposed jury charge, with a missing witness instruction at pages 21 to 22. The charge itself is not publicly available on the docket.

Prosecutors Say Pena Is Available to Both Sides

In a letter filed on 19 November, the government asked the court to withdraw the instruction. Prosecutors presume it is meant to cover the possibility that Pena, identified as Bettor-1 in earlier defence filings, does not testify, and wrote that "the government's decision not to call Pena effectively grants the defendants the relief that they sought."

iGaming glossary: 430+ terms explained.

The letter argues that the Second Circuit case cited for the charge, United States v. Torres (1988), does not support it. It says Clase's lawyers met Pena for several hours in all, and that after an interview in August 2025 Pena signed a sworn declaration that, as a Clase filing described it, "completely denied any communications or discussions with Mr. Clase regarding gambling on baseball". Prosecutors add that they have produced 62 items of Section 3500 witness material on Pena, most of them on 21 August 2026.

Clase and Ortiz each moved before trial to preclude Pena from testifying, the letter notes, and Pena's lawyer, Michael Weil, has repeatedly said Pena will testify if called. Quoting Torres, the letter says courts have been reluctant to find a witness unavailable when the defence has "no real interest in calling the witness to the stand". It argues that the defence is not seeking Pena's evidence because Pena's witness material is "replete with inculpatory information" against the defendants. It asks the court to instruct jurors to draw no inferences against either party, an instruction it says the Second Circuit described as preferred in United States v. Johnson (2024).

The Record Holds Two Accounts From the Same Witness

Pena's August 2025 declaration, as quoted in a Clase filing, denies any discussion of gambling on baseball with Clase; the government says Pena's witness material inculpates the defendants. Neither side has called Pena, and the instruction governs what jurors are told about that.

The Verdict Sheet Puts Vasquez Germosen on One Count

The draft sheet asks the jury about Vasquez Germosen only on Count One, the wire fraud conspiracy against the sportsbooks. Clase and Ortiz alone face Count Two, in which the indictment names their club and MLB as the parties deprived, and the bribery and money laundering conspiracy counts.

The Sportsbooks Are the Alleged Victims on Count One

Count One is the only charge all three defendants face, and the indictment frames it as a scheme to defraud two sportsbooks whose terms of use barred wagers placed on non-public information from an athlete. In August the players' union told Congress that MLB would not join it in lobbying against in-game props and event contracts.

The trial has reached the jury instructions without the government's cooperating bettor in the witness box. The government has asked the court to rule on the instruction before it rests its case.

Sources

Citations and primary documents this article references. Captured at the time of writing.

Comments

Be the first to comment.

Cookie Preferences

Choose which cookies you want to accept. Essential cookies are required for the website to function properly.

Required

Necessary for the website to function. Cannot be disabled.

Help us understand how visitors interact with our website.

Used to deliver relevant advertisements and track ad performance.

Remember your preferences and settings for a better experience.