Skip to content
iGaming Times

Choose your emails

Which emails would you like?

Independent industry intelligence in your inbox. We will email you a link to confirm the emails you ticked, and every email carries a one-click unsubscribe link. Each list can be left on its own.

Prediction Markets

Novig Sues Ohio's Attorney General and Casino Regulators Over Sports Contracts

Antonina TupikovaBy Antonina Tupikova · Founder, iGaming Times2 min read
The Columbus, Ohio skyline and a bridge over the river at dusk

Novig has joined Polymarket and Underdog in suing Ohio's officials over the casino commission's demand that it stop offering sports event contracts. Filed six days after a New York judge ruled against it, the complaint leads with the Commerce Clause.

  • Ludlow Exchange, LLC, which trades as Novig, sued Ohio Attorney General Andy Wilson and the Ohio Casino Control Commission's leadership in federal court on 16 November
  • The suit answers the commission's 2 October cease-and-desist letter, which Novig says warned of administrative, civil, nuisance or criminal action
  • Novig asks the court to declare Ohio's gambling laws discriminatory and preempted as applied to it, and to enjoin their enforcement
  • The complaint argues that the Sixth Circuit's ruling for Ohio against Kalshi is not final and predates the CFTC's 9 October swap rules
  • Novig was among the recipients still holding out in early November; its complaint does not mention the New York ruling against it

Novig Says Ohio Is Threatening a Federally Designated Exchange

Ludlow Exchange filed its 53-page complaint for declaratory and injunctive relief in the US District Court for the Northern District of Ohio on Monday 16 November (No. 1:26-cv-03009). Besides Wilson, it names Interim Executive Director Andromeda Morrison, chair Thomas J. Stickrath and the commission's six other members, all in their official capacities. Judge Charles Esque Fleming is assigned, and Novig told the court the case may be related to Underdog Exchange DCM's pending suit against the same officials, the docket shows.

According to the complaint, Morrison's letter of 2 October said that "Novig is operating online sports gaming" without a licence and is "clearly engaged in bookmaking or facilitating bookmaking". It demanded that Novig stop, including "operating an FCM or DCM that offers sports event contracts to persons located in Ohio", and confirm in writing within 14 days. It claimed power to impose a civil penalty equal to what Novig "has unlawfully obtained or retained" and called its website a nuisance.

Ludlow, a New York-based Delaware company, was formed by Novig, Inc. on 14 October 2025 solely to run a designated contract market (DCM), and the CFTC designated it on 16 June 2026, the complaint says. Novig says rules it added on 12 August set a minimum age of 21 and let users set limits or freeze their accounts.

Commerce Clause First, Preemption Second

Count one alleges that Ohio's sports gaming regime discriminates against interstate commerce. Type A licences go only to applicants with "at least one operational place of business in this state" or an Ohio gaming facility, and other operators must work under contract with one. Servers must sit in Ohio, and wagers may come only from people in the state. That partner route, Novig argues, is one the commission warned its licensees against in August 2025 and again on 20 October.

iGaming glossary: 430+ terms explained.

Count two pleads preemption: Novig's contracts, it argues, are swaps traded on a DCM and so fall within the CFTC's "exclusive jurisdiction". It sets Ohio's geofencing against the CFTC's impartial access rule. "The obstacle is not the expense of compliance, but rather the destruction of the exchange," the complaint says. Novig "does not contend that the Act preempts Ohio's regulation of gambling generally".

KalshiEX LLC v. Schuler, the Sixth Circuit's 25 September ruling for Ohio, is not final, the complaint says: a rehearing petition and three Supreme Court petitions are pending, and Ohio itself has told the Supreme Court the courts are "hopelessly confused and divided". The CFTC's swap rules of 9 October postdate it, and Schuler itself said the CFTC's jurisdiction "displaces direct enforcement and regulatory authority pertaining to the licensing and operation of" DCMs.

Novig seeks a declaration and preliminary and permanent injunctions against enforcement of Ohio's gambling, nuisance and sports gaming chapters, and any other Ohio law used to regulate its event contracts. No response has been filed: the docket shows only the complaint, two supplements, summonses and the judge's assignment.

Novig Follows Polymarket's Order of Battle

The structure matches the suit Polymarket filed on 16 October: the Commerce Clause first, preemption second, and Schuler quoted back at Ohio. Novig adds an argument only an exchange can make: with no house on the other side, a market confined to one state is, "in many contracts", "no market at all". Its own pleading also says that every national online operator serving Ohioans does so under contract with an Ohio proprietor, the route Novig argues an exchange cannot take.

The Colorado Licence Now Cuts Both Ways

In New York, Judge Colleen McMahon used Novig's Colorado licence to find it could seek a state licence and geofence. Here Novig presents the same history, a licence approved in September 2023 and given up after it left that market in April 2024, as proof that state regimes are "structurally incompatible" with an exchange. Ohio may point to the New York court's reading of the same facts.

The Related-Case Flag Puts Novig Beside Underdog

Underdog's case, filed in the same court on 8 September, is before Judge Donald C. Nugent, and the officials' response to its injunction motion was due on 16 November. Novig's flag invites the two to move together. The CFTC, the complaint adds, expects to finalise its amended public interest rule for event contracts by the end of November.

Ohio has not yet answered in court. Until it does, the commission's 2 October demand stands, and Novig's case joins Polymarket's and Underdog's in testing whether a licensing regime built for sportsbooks can apply to a federally designated exchange.

Sources

Citations and primary documents this article references. Captured at the time of writing.

Comments

Be the first to comment.

Cookie Preferences

Choose which cookies you want to accept. Essential cookies are required for the website to function properly.

Required

Necessary for the website to function. Cannot be disabled.

Help us understand how visitors interact with our website.

Used to deliver relevant advertisements and track ad performance.

Remember your preferences and settings for a better experience.