Why the label matters
A spread bet on the total goals in a football match looks like a bet and is taxed with a betting duty. Yet in Britain it is not regulated as gambling. The Gambling Commission's guide says spread betting, which can include betting on stocks and shares, is regulated by the Financial Conduct Authority.
That classification decides which regulator authorises the firm, which rulebook protects the customer and how each side is taxed. It also explains why the product cannot be offered to ordinary retail customers in the United States. Anyone working at, or reporting on, either kind of firm needs this map.
Outside the Gambling Act, inside financial services law
The Gambling Act 2005 defines betting broadly: making or accepting a bet on the outcome of an event, on whether something will happen, or on whether something is true. Section 10 then carves spread bets out. For that definition, "bet" does not include a bet whose making or accepting is a regulated activity under section 22 of the Financial Services and Markets Act 2000.
Section 22 of FSMA makes an activity regulated when it is a specified kind of activity, carried on by way of business, relating to a specified kind of investment. One of the specified investments, in article 85 of the Regulated Activities Order, is rights under a contract for differences, or any other contract meant to secure a profit or avoid a loss by reference to fluctuations in the price of property or in an index. A spread bet fits that description: HMRC itself describes spread betting as betting on the outcome of financial or non-financial fluctuations of an index, whether that index is the FTSE 100 or a football supremacy forecast.
The consequence is FSMA's general prohibition: no person may carry on a regulated activity in the UK unless they are an authorised or exempt person. A spread betting firm therefore needs FCA authorisation, not a Gambling Commission operating licence, and follows the FCA Handbook.
Two kinds of spread bet, two levels of protection
The FCA's retail restrictions do not apply to every spread bet. They cover "restricted speculative investments", defined as leveraged CFDs, leveraged spread bets and leveraged rolling spot forex contracts, but only where they are financial instruments under MiFID. The FCA said plainly that the rules exclude sports spread bets, as its rules only apply to MiFID financial instruments.
So a customer betting £10 a point on the FTSE 100 gets the full package described below. A customer betting £10 a point on total match goals deals with an FCA-authorised firm but is outside that package: none of the COBS 22.5 rules on minimum margin, the 50% close-out or negative balance protection applies.
The FCA's retail rules, as at November 2026
On 27 March 2018 the European Securities and Markets Authority (ESMA), using temporary powers under Article 40 of MiFIR, agreed to restrict CFD sales to retail investors. Its measure applied from 1 August 2018 and was renewed in three-month periods, so national regulators made permanent rules of their own.
The FCA did so in policy statement PS19/18, published in July 2019, with rules in force from 1 August 2019 for CFDs. The FCA's CFD page, last updated on 13 June 2025, confirms that these rules are in the Handbook at COBS 22.5. For a retail client, a firm must:
- Collect minimum margin, in cash. Leverage is capped at 30:1 to 2:1 by underlying; lesson 3 works through the margin table. One UK difference: the FCA allows 30:1 on certain government bonds rather than ESMA's 5:1.
- Close out at 50%. Net equity must not fall below 50% of the margin needed to maintain open positions, and the firm must explain in advance how the close-out level is calculated.
- Give negative balance protection. A retail client's liability is limited to the funds in that account.
- Offer no incentives. No monetary or non-monetary incentives, including account-opening bonuses and fee rebates, including volume-based rebates.
- Show the standardised risk warning. It begins: "CFDs are complex instruments and come with a high risk of losing money rapidly due to leverage", followed by the percentage of the firm's own retail accounts that lost money. The figure is recalculated every three months over the previous 12, including all costs, and the warning sits in its own border, fixed at the top of the screen online. Lesson 6 looks at what the published percentages show.
The FCA went further on one asset class. Rules published in October 2020 banned, from 6 January 2021, the sale of CFDs, options, futures and ETNs referencing certain cryptoassets to retail consumers.
How spread betting is taxed in the UK
The firm pays a betting duty. HMRC charges General Betting Duty on spread bets where a customer makes a bet with a bookmaker who is in the UK. As at November 2026 the rates are 3% for financial spread bets and 10% for all other spread bets, against 15% for fixed-odds and totalisator bets, charged on profits, broadly stakes received less winnings paid out. Duty changes published on 26 November 2025 introduce a 25% rate for remote general bets from 1 April 2027, but state that the rates for financial and non-financial spread bets remain unchanged.
The customer normally pays nothing on winnings. Section 51 of the Taxation of Chargeable Gains Act 1992 provides that winnings from betting are not chargeable gains. HMRC's Capital Gains Manual applies that to spread betting: no assets are acquired or disposed of and no chargeable gains or allowable losses arise. On income tax, HMRC's view is that a person placing a spread bet is not normally carrying on a trade, is not taxable on the profits and gets no relief for losses, while the firm organising the bet is taxable on its profits.
Two qualifications matter. First, where bets arise from carrying on a trade, HMRC says whether a spread bet is taxable depends on the terms of the contract and the economic substance of what is done. Second, a CFD on the same index is treated differently: HMRC's worked example shows a closed CFD producing a chargeable gain, or on a loss an allowable loss. Identical market risk can carry opposite tax results. None of this is personal tax advice.
Ireland and the rest of the EU
On 12 June 2019 the Central Bank of Ireland announced a restriction on CFD sales to retail investors, the first use of the product intervention powers it gained in 2018. Its measure, which took effect on 1 August 2019, states that the CFDs in scope include rolling spot forex products and financial spread bets. It mirrors ESMA's package: margin from 3.33% for major currency pairs to 20% for shares, close-out below half the initial margin, negative balance protection per account, no incentives and a standardised risk warning.
The United States
The US route is closed for a different reason. In their 2012 joint rule defining swaps, the CFTC and SEC stated that CFDs, unless otherwise excluded, fall within the swap or security-based swap definition. The Commodity Exchange Act then makes it unlawful for anyone other than an eligible contract participant to enter into a swap unless it is on, or subject to the rules of, a designated contract market. The Securities Exchange Act has a parallel rule for security-based swaps, which must be effected on a registered national securities exchange when the counterparty is not an eligible contract participant.
Unless a product falls within an exclusion, an off-exchange CFD or financial spread bet with an ordinary retail customer therefore has no lawful route in the US: retail derivatives must trade on regulated exchanges.
Using this map
- Ask which product it is. Financial spread bet, sports spread bet or CFD decides whether COBS 22.5 applies, the firm's duty rate and the customer's tax.
- Check authorisation. A UK spread betting firm should be FCA-authorised; a Gambling Commission licence is the wrong credential.
- Look for the warning. A UK financial spread betting site should show the standardised risk warning, with a firm-specific percentage, fixed at the top of every page.
- Read tax claims carefully. "Tax-free" describes the customer's usual position and comes with no relief for losses.
- Common mistakes. Calling spread betting gambling-regulated, assuming sports spread bets carry negative balance protection, treating 3% duty as a tax on customers, and assuming a UK firm can serve US retail customers.