Fourth Circuit Upholds Denial of Kalshi's Bid to Stop Maryland in 2-1 Ruling
By Antonina Tupikova · Founder, iGaming Times2 min read
A divided panel has affirmed a federal judge's refusal to stop Maryland enforcing its sports wagering law against Kalshi. The one-line per curiam gives no reasons, and the two judges in the majority took different routes.
- The US Court of Appeals for the Fourth Circuit on 17 November affirmed, 2 to 1, the District of Maryland's denial of a preliminary injunction to Kalshi in KalshiEX LLC v. Martin
- The published per curiam only affirms; the reasoning sits in two concurrences
- Judge Gregory left open whether the contracts are swaps and found Maryland has concurrent authority until Congress and the CFTC are clear; Judge Thacker held they are not swaps, as the Ninth Circuit did for Nevada
- Judge Benjamin dissented, finding the contracts are swaps within the Commodity Futures Trading Commission's (CFTC) exclusive jurisdiction and Maryland's law field preempted
- Judge Gregory's concurrence says federal appeals courts have "reached no consensus", citing the Third, Sixth and Ninth Circuits
A One-Line Ruling Leaves Kalshi Without an Injunction Against Maryland
The Fourth Circuit's published opinion of Tuesday 17 November follows argument on 7 May 2026 before Judges Gregory, Thacker and Benjamin. The per curiam reads in full: "The judgment of the district court is AFFIRMED."
According to Judge Gregory's concurrence, Maryland's gaming authorities sent Kalshi a cease-and-desist letter on 7 April 2025 saying it was offering "wagering on sporting events" without a state licence. Kalshi sued on 21 April 2025, arguing that the Commodity Exchange Act (CEA) preempts Maryland's sports wagering laws. District Judge Adam B. Abelson refused a preliminary injunction on 1 August 2025, finding Congress had not "clearly and manifestly intended to strip states of their authority to regulate gambling", and did not reach the other injunction factors. The appeal therefore turned on whether Kalshi was likely to succeed, not on a final judgment.
The caption lists Paradigm Operations LP and Underdog Sports Holding as amici for Kalshi. Supporting Maryland were Nevada, Ohio, 36 other states and the District of Columbia, the American Gaming Association, tribal gaming groups and 30 federally recognised tribes.
Two Concurrences Reach the Same Result by Different Routes
"I do not decide whether Kalshi's sports event contracts are 'swaps' within the meaning of the CEA," Judge Gregory wrote. Read alongside the Special Rule on gaming contracts and the CFTC's Rule 40.11, the CFTC's exclusive jurisdiction does not clearly displace state law, the concurrence finds, noting that the agency's 2026 rulemaking proposals "remain pending". "Kalshi cannot manufacture a conflict by choosing not to comply with one sovereign's otherwise valid regulatory requirements," it adds. It ends: "Until Congress and the CFTC are clear, I conclude that Maryland has concurrent authority under these facts."

Judge Thacker concurred in the judgment: "I get there via a different route than does my concurring colleague." A swap turns on an event's occurrence, the opinion reasons, and "the outcome of an event is not the occurrence of the event". It adds: "What is happening here is sports betting." Therefore, Judge Thacker wrote, "Maryland officials can co-regulate these contracts."
The Dissent Would Have Vacated and Remanded
Judge Benjamin said Judge Thacker's reading "artificially narrows the meaning of 'event'", and that "if Kalshi's sports-related contracts are held to be 'swaps' under the CEA, the CFTC is conferred exclusive jurisdiction, and field preemption applies." The dissent calls the criticism that Kalshi's platform "walks like a casino, swims like a casino, and quacks like a casino" one that "appears logical. But that's not what Congress said." It finds that "Kalshi has demonstrated a likelihood of success" and would have sent the case back for the other factors to be weighed.
The dissent cites the Third Circuit's Flaherty ruling in support of field preemption and the Sixth Circuit's Schuler ruling as contrary, and notes that the Ninth Circuit's Assad ruling drew the same line between an event and its outcome as Judge Thacker. New Jersey's Supreme Court petition in Flaherty is pending.
No Opinion Speaks for a Majority on Swaps
On whether the contracts are swaps, the three judges give three answers: Judge Thacker says no, Judge Benjamin says yes, and Judge Gregory declines to decide. Judge Benjamin's footnote departs from Judge Gregory there, saying a finding of preemption "depends upon Kalshi's sports-related contracts qualifying as 'swaps.'"
The Concurrence and the Dissent Read the CFTC's Inaction in Opposite Ways
Judge Gregory writes that "Nothing in the CEA or the CFTC's regulations converts agency inaction into a determination carrying sweeping preemptive consequences." Judge Benjamin disagrees: the CFTC not having disapproved the contracts "doesn't mean Maryland can regulate Kalshi in its place."
The appeal leaves Kalshi without the injunction it sought against Maryland's licensing law. The two judges who affirmed agree on that result, but not on why.


