Skip to content
iGaming Times

Choose your emails

Which emails would you like?

Independent industry intelligence in your inbox. We will email you a link to confirm the emails you ticked, and every email carries a one-click unsubscribe link. Each list can be left on its own.

Prediction Markets

43 States and DC Tell the CFTC to Withdraw Its Swap Rule for Sports Contracts

Antonina TupikovaBy Antonina Tupikova · Founder, iGaming Times2 min read
The dome of the US Capitol with an American flag flying in front of it against a blue sky

Attorneys general for 43 states and the District of Columbia used the last day of comment to tell the Commodity Futures Trading Commission that sports contracts are not swaps and that its sportsbook carve-out draws the wrong line. The proposal's docket, which held 11 comments on 9 November, now holds 142.

  • Two comment letters dated 18 November, the closing date, carry the signatures of the attorneys general of 43 states and the District of Columbia
  • An Ohio-led letter asks the CFTC to withdraw its proposal to define event contracts, sports included, as swaps, arguing that it lacks statutory authority and a quorum
  • A Maryland-led letter on the interim rule excluding licensed sportsbooks and casinos asks for the exclusion to cover all state-regulated gambling
  • Florida, Georgia, Indiana, Montana, New Hampshire, North Dakota and Texas are the seven states missing from both letters
  • The proposal had 11 comments and none from the states when iGT reported on 9 November; it had 142 by 20 November

The States Filed Two Letters With the Same 44 Signatures on the Deadline

The Nebraska Attorney General's office posted the two letters on Wednesday 18 November, announcing that Attorney General Mike Hilgers had joined them. Both are dated 18 November, the closing date for comment on the two swap rules the Commodity Futures Trading Commission (CFTC) published on 19 October, and each carries the same 44 signatures.

The letter on the proposal to bring event contracts into the swap definition is on Ohio letterhead and signed first by Ohio Attorney General Andy Wilson. The letter on the interim final rule is signed first by Maryland Attorney General Anthony G. Brown. Both name Kentucky, Nevada, New Jersey, New York, Tennessee and Utah alongside Ohio and Maryland.

Ohio's Letter Says Sports Bets Are Not Swaps and the CFTC Cannot Make Them So

The Ohio-led letter argues that sports bets are not "commonly known to the trade" as swaps and are not tied to an event with financial consequences. It cites rulings against the CFTC's reading in the Sixth and Ninth Circuits, and says the major-questions doctrine and the federalism canon require a clear statement from Congress that the Commodity Exchange Act lacks.

The letter says a footnote stating that the Securities and Exchange Commission "joins" does not meet the statute's demand for a joint rule. It argues that the CFTC, whose only commissioner is Chairman Michael Selig, lacks a quorum to make rules, and cannot override the Sixth and Ninth Circuits within those circuits.

iGaming glossary: 430+ terms explained.

The states also say the proposal ignores gambling harm, with no age limits, self-exclusion or licensing, and ignores reliance on the CFTC's 2024 statement that it "is not a gaming regulator". A footnote adds that several signatories object to politics, election, weather and culture contracts for the same reasons. The letter concludes that the CFTC "should withdraw the Proposed Rule" and "start afresh".

Maryland's Letter Says the Carve-Out Draws the Wrong Line

The Maryland-led letter agrees that states traditionally regulate gambling, but objects that the exclusion covers licensed operators' wagers and not products traded on a multilateral market. State law, it says, covers "any system or method of wagering", including exchange wagering, parimutuel pools and percentage games, so the claim that gambling is house-based is "simply false".

The letter says that under the reasoning of the interim rule and the companion proposal, horse racing tracks running parimutuel betting would be "currently operating criminal enterprises", a result it calls absurd. It also argues that the CFTC had no good cause to skip prior notice and comment, and says the agency "can maintain consistency only by expanding its exclusion to include all state-regulated gambling".

The Docket Filled Up in the Final Days

According to the Regulations.gov counts the Federal Register carried on 20 November, the proposal drew 142 comments and the interim rule 124, against 11 and seven on 9 November. Filers on the proposal's docket include Kalshi, Polymarket US, Coinbase, Cboe Global Markets, the American Gaming Association, the Nevada Resort Association, Boyd Gaming, the National Congress of American Indians and dozens of tribes and tribal gaming bodies. The State of Utah also filed on its own.

The States Have Put Their Court Arguments Into the Rulemaking Record

The two letters place in the administrative record the arguments the states have pressed in court, down to the Fourth Circuit's Maryland decision of 18 November. The Ohio-led letter adds a fallback: any final rule could apply only prospectively, leaving states free to act on contracts offered before it takes effect.

The Boundary Each Letter Asks For

Ohio's letter names, as the alternative the CFTC failed to consider, excluding sports and casino-style contracts even when a prediction market offers them; Maryland's asks that the exclusion cover all state-regulated gambling. The quorum objection is not tied to the swap question and applies to any rule the CFTC issues while Selig is its only commissioner. President Trump has nominated two more commissioners.

Sources

Citations and primary documents this article references. Captured at the time of writing.

Comments

Be the first to comment.

Cookie Preferences

Choose which cookies you want to accept. Essential cookies are required for the website to function properly.

Required

Necessary for the website to function. Cannot be disabled.

Help us understand how visitors interact with our website.

Used to deliver relevant advertisements and track ad performance.

Remember your preferences and settings for a better experience.